[eksu]

Isn’t that point based on the possibly incorrect assumption Columbus doesn’t have a chance?

And if their odds really are slim, wouldn’t the rational choice for Columbus to make be to offer tax breaks?

Like, why is the actor that is Columbus concerned at all if they put some sort of pressure on Boston/NYC/DC?

(I think HQ2 will be Columbus or Denver).

[pythonaut_16]

I agree. I think Amazon cares a lot more about logistics and future growth than the specific tax incentives being offered.

The prevailing claim that Amazon has already chosen and is trying to extract better incentives seems wrong to me. If that was the case Amazon could have approached ~5 cities from the start with a plan for each and put a far stronger competitive pressure on them.

I think what this is really about is getting the cities to do the leg work of the research and initial planning process. Amazon wasn't going to put together 200 initial site proposals and 20 more detailed ones. By letting the cities make the proposals Amazon can look at far more potential sites than if they had done the research internally.

[_gutd]

IMHO the biggest issue for some of the smaller cities is attracting talent. Good luck getting top notch twenty-something engineers to move to Indy when all of their buddies are in SF, NYC, Boston, etc. Guess I'll eat my words if HQ2 ends up being in the midwest, but this seems like an insurmountable hurdle for the little guys.

[softawre]

Indy has Rose Hulman and Purdue, both of which pump out pretty good software engineers. Are they on par with the SV types? Maybe not, but you're not paying them 300k either.

For what it's worth, I live in Indy and I get emails from Amazon every week trying to get me to work somewhere fairly close to here (like Detroit).

[padobson]

Indy has Rose Hulman and Purdue

University of Illinois has top notch CS grads too, pretty close to Indy. Seems like the most likely reason they made the list.

Indy also has underrated infrastructure - having to host the massive event that is the Indy 500 every year has given the city experience in dealing with large influxes of travelers.

[kilotaras]

And that's where those H1B come in.

[tzahola]

“top notch twenty-something”

LoL