Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by o2348diuu 3067 days ago
This piece hits close to home, as it's really clear to me I am going through a midlife crisis and have interesting parallels and contrasts with the author in terms of my career and next steps.

What seems to me to be the heart of this piece is the telic-atelic distinction, which seems useful and deserving of more attention. There's some parallels, it seems, between the telic-atelic distinction on the one hand, and the distinction between more stereotypical "western" goal-oriented notions of success or happiness, and recent foci of mindfulness and other things having a kind of Buddhist bent. To me the telic-atelic distinction seems useful if for no other reason than to provide an additional historical and philosophical context to something gaining in the public consciousness. The atelic ideal seems similar to the mindfulness goals, but framed differently, in terms of types of rewards.

For me, although useful, I'm not sure this explains all of the midlife crisis. Maybe a big chunk, but for me personally at least I'd say more of it is about feeling like I took a wrong turn with certain choices, and feeling like there's no way to get out of it due to the limits of lifespan and sociocultural failings (e.g., stereotypes about age, gender, and profession, and ability to change, etc.). For me it's been less about asking "is this all there is?" and more like feeling like I've come to the conclusion that my vocation is a fraud, or that I'm not a good fit, and that humans in general are far more flawed and darker than I realized. There were similar feelings about other things in my early adulthood, but I always felt I could change my life, improve things, and move to something else; the difference is now, I feel like the change is more substantial due to the costs and investments involved, and I feel like societal stereotypes and failings make it harder. There's also the limitations of lifespan which are very real and make things difficult.

I feel profoundly disappointed in life and people, in the sense of being wronged, not in the sense of being bored. I don't want to feel this way, but am not sure how to get out of it.

6 comments

> I don't want to feel this way, but am not sure how to get out of it.

Start seeing a therapist, changed my life

I also really liked the telic-atelic distinction and would like to read more about it. But this:

> stereotypical "western" goal-oriented notions of success or happiness

is probably more "American" than "western". Look at the laissez-faire life of the French, Spanish or Italians and the typical German surely doesn't thrive for success but for a stable, comfortable life.

That goal-hunting and search for exceptionalism is certainly spreading in the world but I would think that the American culture is maybe the only one where it is really rooted.

>> I feel profoundly disappointed in life and people, in the sense of being wronged

I suspect there is a notion of "things ought to be a certain/right way" in your view of things. I feel this defense is often used to justify to oneself why one hasn't engaged in something/the world. Said another way, it is safer to think things should work a certain way instead of risking for oneself to find out. It's never too late to find out directly.

I also feel like I made some wrong turns in my life and turn in the right direction is almost impossible now: career- and, what is the saddest part, family-wise. It just feels like it's too late for everything to get back on track. Damn. I'll be 35 in a couple of months :(
There was a story on NPR a while back about a guy that became an oncologist at 50. Major career change from where he was in life.

Any time I feel on the wrong track, thinking of this guy makes my course corrections seem more doable.

My advice would be, if you're not already, take up some kind of sport/exercise like running, join a club. If that doesn't work, buy a motorcycle... Actually get one anyway, it is the traditional way.
They say you never see motorcycles in front of therapist’s office.
Ecclesiastes has helped me.