| You know the phrase "round up the usual suspects"? It's the same root idea: the goal of the system is not to find the person who committed the crime. The goal of the system is, for each crime, to find a person who can be nailed for it. And you can manufacture a class of people such that whenever you need an offender you can go grab some of them and stand a good chance at getting a guilty plea or a conviction. You start by selectively hyper-enforcing small violations against a chosen subset of the population. Get them for minor traffic violations (which you can ensure turn into arrest warrants by setting the fines and fees and other costs high enough!), get them for "paraphernalia" offenses (where you assume everyday objects in Person A's possession are evidence of drug habits while they wouldn't be assumed evidence in the possession of Person B!), get them for all sorts of things. Now whenever there's a crime you just go pick some random people from the demographic you've been doing this to, figure out who you can bribe to testify against whom, and then march into the courtroom with witnesses and a defendant who has a thick file of previous "encounters" with the system, and off to a cell they go for a while. And it gets even easier each go-round: people with criminal records don't usually have the resources to move on and rebuild their lives, so once they're released they're going to be right back where you found them last time. And they've got an even longer record now, which is just proof that you've been doing a great job in figuring out who these dangerous recidivists are! The model works! |
I know it goes against some cherished beliefs, but this really is how much of the US handles "justice".