If it was created as a portfolio piece, I'd say it's successful. If it was created as useful and repeatable reference for the digital product/service/whatever industry, it falls short.
I don't think it's trying to be a definitive reference. It seems more like those posters you put around the office to remind you of things you value or you think are important.
Everyone is taking this fairly seriously. I doubt HN is the target demographic for this sort of thing though.
Everyone is taking this fairly seriously. I doubt HN is the target demographic for this sort of thing though.