[nonbel]

> "Do they? I mean, the qualia of "I'm having a lucid dream" might not have 100% overlap with the fact of having a lucid dream."

I cover this objection in the next sentence:

>"If you will not trust their self report of that info there is no reason to trust anything else they report about the dream either."

If you don't trust the self report of such basic aspects of the dream, why would you believe anything they say about it at all? Either way, the "LuCiD" scale they came up with is unhelpful for identifying lucid dreaming.