[chimeracoder]

> The point of a to-do list (or reminder in Google Calendar) is that it's constantly staring at you until you actually complete it. It sounds like you're using one-off calendar entries. I'm not suggesting that "try not having ADD", just suggesting you use mechanisms to remind you to do stuff that are persistent and thus work.

No offense, but from what you're saying, it's pretty clear you don't understand how ADHD works. ADHD is a disorder that affects executive function; the whole problem is that the system you're describing will fail for someone with even moderate but untreated ADHD, let alone more severe cases.

Maybe you don't mean it this way, but it's actually rather insulting to say that these mechanisms "are persistent and thus work", or that OP try a to-do list because "it's constantly staring at you until you actually complete it". ADHD means that you can't assume that those systems work, and it means that "constantly starting at you until you complete it" isn't actually a viable solution.

Hence, that's why OP read your post as "try not having ADD", because you're literally suggesting solutions that presume that they not have ADHD in the first place.

[YeGoblynQueenne]

>> Hence, that's why OP read your post as "try not having ADD", because you're literally suggesting solutions that presume that they not have ADHD in the first place.

To be fair, the article does make the point pretty strongly that it is very hard to separate ADHD from natural variations of attention, concentration etc:

  But “ability to concentrate” is a normally distributed trait, like IQ. We draw a 
  line at some point on the far left of the bell curve and tell the people on the far 
  side that they’ve “got” “the disease” of “ADHD”. This isn’t just me saying this. 
  It’s the neurostructural literature, the the genetics literature, a bunch of other 
  studies, and the the Consensus Conference On ADHD. This doesn’t mean ADHD is “just 
  laziness” or “isn’t biological” – of course it’s biological! Height is biological! 
  But that doesn’t mean the world is divided into two natural categories of “healthy 
  people” and “people who have Height Deficiency Syndrome“. Attention is the same 
  way. Some people really do have poor concentration, they suffer a lot from it, and 
  it’s not their fault. They just don’t form a discrete population.

Also, if attention etc is a "normally distributed trait", any behavioural intervention that can help someone near the middle of the distribution has a pretty good chance of helping someone near the extremes, also. To take the example of height again, just because someone is short doesn't mean they won't look taller with high heels.

In fact, if you think about it, such interventions are designed exactly to help people with poor executive function, as you say. Assuming that this is basically a description of what ADHD is, I don't see why behavioural interventions can't make a dent in it.

[Sir_Substance]

>To take the example of height again, just because someone is short doesn't mean they won't look taller with high heels.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lbMv0UkAswI&feature=youtu.be...

[YeGoblynQueenne]

That's a funny video, but what am I expected to get from it?

[CydeWeys]

How does a persistent in-your-face reminder that does not go away until completed fail? I suppose severe procrastination or complete lack of willpower would do it, but are these not different from ADHD?

[karmajunkie]

Its in your face.

For people with ADHD, its a distraction that's willfully ignored while you're trying to complete one of the other hundred things on your to-do list that are also screaming for attention, most of them in more-urgent-but-less-important ways that this attempt to schedule an appointment with yet another provider who's likely going to make you prove once again that your life is falling apart by jumping through your life story and maybe trying some alternative that makes you ill, cranky, and introduces some sexual dysfunction that gives you one more thing to worry about alongside the thoughts of whatdoigetdonethisweekpleasejustletmecrossoffonethingtoday that you wake up to each morning.

> severe procrastination or complete lack of willpower

This sounds an awful lot like the attribution of a moral failing to people that suffer from an issue with executive function as it pertains to attention. This might be why people keep telling you that you are clearly articulating an inability to empathize. Imagine a mindset in which your fundamental assumptions, which seem self-evident to you, do not apply. If it seems difficult to understand why anybody would want to live that way, congratulations, you've got something in common! Nobody else wants to live that way either—the difference is that we don't have much of a choice, which is why we all have such strong opinions about this topic.

[costatus]

CydeWeys - thanks for your persistent posts... they are a wonderful example of how someone without the condition cannot fathom what is going on "inside" and thinks they can be fixed with a system or willpower. These things help to a point but there is an underlying problem that can't be fixed this way.

[fragmede]

Easy, just close the browser tab and never use calendar or keep ever again.

Rational? Far from it. Functional? Nope.

That's why it's a disease but we have medication to treat it.

It's like trying to tell someone that walking is easy, just put one foot in front of the other - to someone with no legs. Unfortunately it's harder to see missing legs for mental diseases.

[turtle789]

No, those are often core problems in ADHD. This is (much of) what it means to have poor executive function.