Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by wellboy 3095 days ago
Why not reward computation power by the amount of kwh they have spent, regardless of if their computation was worth it or worthless.
3 comments

kWh isn’t a good metric of computational output though. You want to encourage people to do more useful work for you; if that means they should tune their code for a fancy GPU, then kWh probably won’t correlate (a single package server CPU is about 145W, a server class GPU about 300W, but the GPU usually performs way more compute).
I'm sorry, but the world does not work the way that you want it to.
Then you have to verify, and as he says, you end up duplicating the work.
duplicating is very optimistic. Over a distributed network, to achieve trust, it will have to be (n) where n is the average (over all time) number of agents that care about the validity of the chain. Then don't forget to multiply by k^2 where k is the expected blockchain chain length over all time. As an approximation...