Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by docdeek 3103 days ago
It depends on where you are, I guess. I pay for data on my cell in France but the amount of data I am allowed each month before things start to slow down (100GB, up from 50GB a few months ago) means I never get close to getting throttled by auto-playing videos.
3 comments

> 100 GB

Just across the border, in Germany, a usual data plan includes only 1-4 GB before slowdown to 2G.

The French data plan even includes 25 GB of roaming which you can use in Germany, IIRC you can choose between Telekom or Vodafone network. Unfortunately, you still have to be in France most of the time, or they will cancel your contract.
Lucky you. I'm in France and I got 50 Mo before starting to pay for my data. Granted, I'm using the old 5€ offering from Orange (called Sosh), because I'm not using a lot of data (no video, very few pictures, some text) and I'm too lazy to change. Also I'm not sure my phone can support another mobile network.
You need a phone that supports LTE for the Free contract, otherwise you only get 3 GB of data.
Oh I'm pretty sure my phone support LTE, but I'm saying that the phone might be locked to a provider (Orange) and will reject any SIM not from it. Since the phone is originally from a company which has an exclusive contract with Orange for all mobile hardware and subscriptions, it is not surprising.
How much do you pay for that plan?
20 euros per month with "Free" (that's the name of the company) ISP.

"Free" has his share of problems, notably many people complain that the quality of their connection is strenuous at best, some people don't. It's a bit of gamble with them.

What can't be denied is that in France there was a before-Free and an after-Free. They introduced 20gb for 20E/month when everybody else was at 5gb for 50E/month (not the exact amounts, but it was that ballpark). The result is that the other ISP had to align themselves with Free, and now you have a lot of other similar offers to choose from. Yay Free.

Yes I think France had the same problem we have (and are gonna have again) in The Netherlands.

We used to have a lot of providers, that merged into three big ones (KPN, Vodafone, T-mobile). Despite them not colluding, they basically price-matched each other which meant we had some of the highest prices in Europe.

Then Tele2 came into the market as a new player. Before Tele2 it wasn't uncommon to pay €20-30 for 2GB of data + 100 texts/minutes. Tele2 started with 25GB (don't know the texts/minutes) for €25, and now it is €25 for unlimited. Plus there are many MNVOs offering even cheaper prices, and this all combined forces the big three to follow the market.

However, T-mobile is going to buy the Dutch part of Tele2, so now we will have 3 big players again, and it is almost certain prices will rise and innovation will slow. The EU even did research and concluded that for a healthy competitive telecommunications market you need at least 4 providers.

Edit/extra info:

We have a regulatory organisation (ACM) but they are utterly spineless. For example, in The Netherlands KPN used to be a state company, and when they were privatised they basically got the entire copper grid for pennies on the euro. Because of this the ACM later ordered that they must allow other companies to hire those lines. This is all good.

But then there is the cable grid, which was built by private companies and then in the end either owned by UPC or Ziggo (so duopoly on our cable grid). ACM then allowed those two to merge, resulting in Ziggo owning ~50% of the internet market in NL, and being a monopoly provider in a lot of parts in The Netherlands. You guessed it, they have raised prices 3-4x in the last few years, waiting times for calling customer service went from a few minutes to 20+ minutes.. etc.

For clarification: in NL due to lots of mergers (and because the companies are aware that landline internet will go the way of landline calling) most telecommunication companies are both landline and mobile providers. You have Vodafone-Ziggo, KPN and T-mobile.

Price plans in Denmark from CBB Mobile for comparison (most providers around these price points):

- Unlimited voice - Unlimited text (SMS+MMS) - 30 GB Data in Denmark DKK 129 (EUR 17 / USD 21)

- Unlimited voice - Unlimited text (SMS+MMS) - 40 GB Data in Denmark - 6 GB Data within EU DKK 149 (EUR 20 / USD 24)

Low cost plan with 6 hours of voice and 4 GB data at DKK 79 (11 EUR / USD 13)

Cheapest plan is DKK 19 (EUR 2,5 / USD 3) with everything metered.

It's usually around 20€/month for that kind of plan in France (with unlimited calls and SMS).