Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sergiotapia 3111 days ago
It's bcash.

From /r/bitcoin:

>Starting a new company called Apple Unlimited! Please don't confuse this with our competitor, Apple. We did "borrow" all of their code, but we claim to follow the wishes of the great Steve Jobs, because the new guys that took over are ruining everything and censoring everyone!
2 comments
takeda 3111 days ago
Bitcoin Cash is closer to original Bitcoin than Bitcoin Core. What makes one more worthy of the name than the other? Both are forks.
link
Frogolocalypse 3111 days ago
You can still run a 0.8 node on the bitcoin network if you are so inclined, because changes have been implemented via soft-forks. Bcash is a hard-fork of bitcoin. It is not bitcoin, or you would be able to use your existing wallets with it.
link
joseluis 3110 days ago
Soft doesn't mean it's still Bitcoin. This word doesn't grasp the true difference between these fork kinds. What is it? Softfok is a coercive change. You can't oppose it unless you make some counter-hardfork (this is what happened in Bitcoin Cash). Softfork is a sneaky change that non upgraded nodes don't notice. Meanwhile, hardfork (especially with replay protection) leaves everyone the freedom of accepting it or not and make it obvious to nodes that it happened.

These are technical terms that were fine when used technically by technical people who understand them. But they are kind of loaded what can be used to trick nontechnical people into believing that 'hard' means 'big' and 'soft' means 'small'. And 'big' means 'abandonment of true bitcoin' while 'soft' means 'still following the true bitcoin'.

Easy thought experiments can prove these is not the case. Let's think of some possible changes that can be made as softforks and are clearly a violation of the original idea:

- a requirement that every transaction has an additional output for tax collection

- a requirement that every transaction contains KYC/AML tag. - addresses blacklist

- decreasing the max block size to 10 kB

- lowering the block reward to 0 from tomorrow, miners get only tx fees (it is possible because the protocol defined the max block reward rather than exact block reward)

- adding a second PoW algo (it can be put in coinbase)

- a requirement for coinbase to contain a specific Quran verse

https://www.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/7jehc2/we_should_aband...

link
sincerely 3111 days ago
Fortunately for everyone involved, this isn't r/bitcoin
link