Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 3111 days ago
There is no such thing as analog telephony anymore, and there hasn't been for a long time. While you might still have analog local loops, the network has been completely digital for a long time, be it ISDN or VoIP, and VoIP is perfectly capable of transmitting ISDN voice data without recoding.
1 comments

I think what might be being referred to as "analog telephony" is actually the "original digital" system using 64Kbps "uncompressed" PCM, vs. VoIP compressed audio at much lower bitrates. It's like the difference between CD and MP3.
I would be very surprised if any telco were using any sort of compression internally (other than G.711, obviously). 64 kb/s with RTP/IP framing overhead is about 100 kb/s, that's just not a lot of bandwidth anymore that it would be worth installing hardware to do de-/compression. Even a gigabit link can carry ~ 10000 such calls--that's a drop in the bucket compared to the internet needs of the many more than 10000 subscribers that you need to ever have 10000 concurrent calls (probably more in the range hundreds of gigabits, possibly terabits).