[dingo_bat]

> but most people agree its warranted

Is it warranted for you to kill me if I steal your car?

[RhodesianHunter]

I know you're being facetious, but in many states legally yes, provided you're caught in the act.

[dingo_bat]

I am not being facetious. IMO, it is not warranted for anybody to break laws in retaliation to another person breaking a law.

[jlillyreed]

I agree with you.

however, the people murdering the thief would claim that they are not breaking any laws.