Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by nradov 3122 days ago
Nope that doesn't work because there's still no way to reliably control for the confounding factors. We don't even know what all the confounding factors are. Patients aren't randomly assigned to providers.
1 comments

> Patients aren't randomly assigned to providers.

Sure, we don't have that information today. But, if we want to collect relevant information we could easily have a subset of doctors with random patient assignment. IMO, that's simply an implementation detail required if we want good information.

PS: US healthcare spending is over 3 trillion per year, rationally even minor improvements are worth large investments.

None of that is actually easy. Spend a few years working in a clinical environment and then tell us how easily it could be done.
I do work in healthcare for HHS this is very much the kind of thing we do. Change is hard, data collection is significantly easier.