Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by pavlov 3120 days ago
At least in the case of France, the point seems valid, and it's perhaps opposite of what you're assuming.

The modern French nation is actually a left-wing construct -- an intentional product of the French Revolution. The Kingdom of France was not really a unified nation-state as we understand them today. There were multiple languages and a rich spectrum of local identities. French subjects were not necessarily French-speaking: their native tongue could just as well be Provençal, Italian or something else, and the King didn't really care.

The Revolution triggered local counter-revolutions of people who didn't necessarily think themselves as French in the sense that the new government in Paris wanted them to. (The War in the Vendée was a particularly bloody local war even by Revolution standards: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_in_the_Vendée)

To counter the insurgencies and establish their new order, the Revolutionary authorities set about to explicitly design what a French citizen should be. The predominance of the French language was one element of this.

1 comments

Napoleon (whose political views were across the board, but fairly right-wing) had more say about establishing the French state than any of the revolutionaries that had power before him. The Code Napoleon, for example.