Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by windlessstorm 3125 days ago
Tiny microprocessors are there in almost all devices supporting DMA since long time right? So what this RISC-V versions will bring new to the table?
1 comments

> So what this RISC-V versions will bring new to the table?

Not much, except being open, so WD can produce them without paying anyone royalties.

But in that case there would not be much of a point in making such an announcement, right? From a user perspective, I do not care at all what ISA the microcontroller inside the HDD/SSD uses, if it is not user accessible.

Unless they pass the savings on to their customers, that is. And even then, I am not so sure. Shaving a couple of cents of the price of a disk drive does not seem like a big deal to me.

Their stockholders might care, though.

Depends on what you care about, I suppose. I find it interesting, because I am interested in low-power processors.

This move, if it works well for WD, could lead to more attention being paid to a more open competitor to ARM, which would provide some competition and put downward pressure on ARM pricing. That, in turn, could have some potentially interesting second-order effects.

But yeah, if you only care about consumer prices and visible features, this is probably pretty boring stuff.

Mmmmh, now that I think of it: Does WD have their own fabs, or do they buy their chips from other vendors.

And if it's the latter - would WD buying a couple of billion chips a year have any effect on prices?

And now that you mention it - a company like WD announcing they will use RISC-V in their disks means they are serious about this, which in turn might make it easier for other to consider RISC-V a serious option.

I am very excited about RISC-V in theory, but unless somebody builds a "Raspberry-V", so to speak, it will probably be a long time before I get to play with one of these. I also think a high-performance implementation of RISC-V could make for an attractive component of a desktop machine / workstation. The Talos Raptor / II seems to be a sweet machine, but it is totally outside my budget. A less-high-end machine built around a RISC-V might change the equation.