Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by superbrama 3128 days ago
Dude, cmon. I know this is hn and I’m supposed to put effort into crafting useful responses. But, how have those links convinced you that it must be the mic?

From the evidence in those videos, I’d rather be considering whether fb is part of a future AI continuum monitoring and influencing the past (from the future in which the AI exists) by messing with people testing this feature. Yep, cat is alive on Facebook/IG, days later. Microphones and big data/AI are but two slits through which photons can pass, in the experiment known as fb.
1 comments
logicallee 3128 days ago
What other kind of explanation do you expect? People have tested it by playing a Spanish soap opera on their TV for a few hours, leaving their phone in front of it to listen. They then started getting Spanish advertisements. I realize that there is a confirmation bias in that they are then actively looking for Spanish-language ads (to test their theory) but don't you think they would have noticed them at other times? They explicitly ran an experiment and got the verification.

In fact, some people were incredulous and re-ran the experiment thinking there's no way they would start getting Spanish ads: they did too. That's all it takes to convince me. I mean what other mechanism would get back to Facebook? As far as I know TV's don't report back which specific channel they're tuning into (all channels are streamed concurrently.)

I'm all for a more scientific test but at the moment I find the anecdotal evidence quite convincing. I just outlined how a scientific test might work here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15782323

link
superbrama 3127 days ago
One has to be very thorough when reviewing the details of such investigations. For instance, we would want to look at details regarding the experimenter’s cable tv service. If it’s digital perhaps the viewing data was resold to fb.

At the most in those cases there’s enough info to suggest data sharing is going on at the least, but not enough to confirm anything regarding the fb app itself and the mic.

Worth investigating more, though.

link