Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tinha 3137 days ago
There's a documentary on Netflix about this, I think it's called Sugar x Fat.
2 comments

There's 2 good documentaries I remember about the subject (though there's likely many more): That Sugar Film [1] and Fed Up [2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/That_Sugar_Film

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fed_Up_(film)

'That Sugar Film' is incredibly dishonest.

The guy claims he gained about 15kg over a one month period by substituting sugary foods into his diet while keeping his caloric intake the same. That's a massive claim which you'd expect to be backed up by pretty rigorous testing, yeah? Not even close. He doesn't even count his calories.

The whole time I was watching I was waiting to see the numbers. Spoiler alert: there aren't any. Halfway through the 'experiment' he states that he's never counted calories before, proceeds to do it just once, and then claims that his intake appears to be the same as it was before. To embark on a project like this and only measure your caloric intake once throughout the entire thing is incredibly disingenuous behaviour.

I dont know about Fed Up, but at the very least That Suger Film is very dishonest and not good science. Unfortunately the only good source I have is in swedish, but here it is: https://traningslara.se/hur-du-gor-en-storsaljande-men-usel-...
I am inherently distrustful of anything that tries to demonize a specific foodstuff or nutrient, without bringing some serious evidence to the table.

For instance, the evidence against trans fats is seriously overwhelming and convincing. The evidence against carbohydrates? Eh, not so much.

Avoid added sugar, don't worry so much about bread (as long as you avoid the stuff with added sugar, obviously) or rice or paste or potatoes.

That Sugar Film is good and fun.
+1 to Fed Up.
Does anyone have an opinion on this one, also on Netflix?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What_the_Health

It's pro-veganism and the narrator is a goofy manchild, but has credible (to me anyway) medical experts.

If you read reviews about What the Health online, you'll see that lot of it is vegan propaganda. They've manipulated facts (like mentioning relative probability as opposed to absolute) so that they seem more dangerous than it actually is.
Yeah, I second that. I starts out very credible but if you examine what they say, especially regarding sugar and carbs it becomes very clear that it's vegan propaganda and skewing its facts heavily
It was funded by a vegan propaganda group and has been widely discredited.