[ekr]

I'd be really interested in seeing a double blind test, to check if people really can tell the difference between the two.

[pabloarteel]

It's not about people telling if they can spot which logo is made by a pro vs an app.

For a logo to be effective, it has to communicate an intent/personality/style according to what the brand is about. And the probabilty that an app achieves that is based on pure luck.

I get that generic logos may look "nice", but a logo is not about that.