Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jacobrobbins 3149 days ago
To contrast your single positive account with a single negative account, my brother has been unable to update his Estonian e-Resident card because the system only works reliably on Windows. He has to wait to re-activate until the next time he goes to Estonia.

He has used the system from the outset and describes it as dated. It was built for a pre-mobile era and does not have a full-featured ecosystem for mobile devices.

2 comments

Mine updated OK on OS X. While I have fellow e-residents here...

- Is there a trick to getting "Load picture" (my own photo) to work? All I've ever gotten is "invalid response," and this is on Windows, OS X, and Linux.

- Supposedly new Estonian IDs use ECC rather than RSA, but some articles seem to be confusing whether the once-vulnerable-but-now-regenerated IDs use ECC as well. I don't think that's possible, as the smart-card hardware doesn't appear to support it. Does an ECC key require new hardware for pre-November 2017 cards?

- For those of you who have been following Estonian ID technology for a while, why didn't they use regular OpenPGP cards that would enable cardholders to use ordinary PGP/GPG clients? Did the Estonian standard predate the OpenPGP standard? Or were there technical reasons the Estonian government needed something else?

> Is there a trick to getting "Load picture" (my own photo) to work? All I've ever gotten is "invalid response," and this is on Windows, OS X, and Linux.

No idea. It doesn't work for me either.

Odd. I did mine on Mac with no issues. I agree that the whole system feels clunky.