Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mrmyers 3161 days ago
Why wouldn't the following ordering work? {(x,y) | (|x| ≤ |y|) & ((|x| = |y| & x ≠ y) ⇒ x < 0 < y)}
1 comments

With your ordering, what is the least element of the open interval (0,1)?
What if you order the absolute values of the differences from the midpoint of the interval, where the midpoint is supremum - infimum if bounded, or zero if unbounded? Obviously this fails for closed/open sets like [a,infinity), but wouldn't it work for fully open sets?
Ultimately, the point becomes moot because we focus too much on "normal" sets. Such a definition does nothing to help us answer questions like, what is the least element of the irrationals?
Ah, right. Makes sense.