Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by brokenpromise 3198 days ago
That's not how risk works, though. The probability of dying from a gunshot to the head are basically 1, but the probability of that event happening is basically 0. So it wouldn't make sense to never go outside because getting shot in the head is almost certain death; the risk that matters is of the event itself happening, not the outcome given that the event has already occurred.
1 comments

It wouldn't make sense to never go outside, that is correct.

It would make sense, however, to avoid high crime areas, large and violent gatherings of people like riots, etc.

And if you were truly, truly, truly paranoid, you could wear a kevlar helmet around. People might think you are a complete freak, but war journalists do it.

My point here is, when I'm driving a car, I can control my personal risk.

With flying, most of the risk factors are completely out of my hands. I can only control the number of times I fly. And if they were legal, I could wear a parachute.

> My point here is, when I'm driving a car, I can control my personal risk.

Yeah, if you never looked at the evidence or psychology then I suppose you would come to that conclusion.

> With flying, most of the risk factors are completely out of my hands.

Why do you think flying is so much safer than driving?

Re: your first point, how can you say I have not looked at evidence or psychology?

The aggregate statistics for road deaths and injuries include drunk drivers, high speed two way roads in Wyoming, winter collisions, etc.

I don't drive drunk. I don't drive on high speed two way roads. I don't live in a wintery place.

The aggregate statistics do not represent my driving habits. I am controlling my risk.

Re your second point, yes flying is safe. I don't dispute it. However, people /still die/ while flying. Ok, now why is that?

Planes are hijacked. Engines fail. Planes collide. Planes are shot down.

I can't control the situation once it occurs. I can only choose to not fly.

When I'm driving, I can choose my type of car. I can drive defensively. I can avoid certain roads.

You might think this is just an illusion of control, but how many people have died in a 25 mph crash in a very safe truck on side roads?

How many people have died on two lane roads at night with alcohol involved?

I know that HN is a very specific crowd, but humans are not machines - just because I know flying is safer than driving does not make me feel any better about it. Same reason why I feel very unsafe when I'm a passanger in a car vs. driving myself - I feel in control of the situation, even though statistically it's not a safe situation to be in at all.