Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by JosephLark 3202 days ago
Likely due to GCP competition. I believe GCP was always per-second? [Edit: Misremember that, they were always per-minute. Lots of good information below directly form the related parties.]

Azure looks to be per-hour [Edit: Wrong again, they are per-minute as well. Oddly enough, I did check their pricing page before, but missed the per-minute paragraph and only saw the hourly pricing] but I'm seeing something about container instances possibly being per-second.
3 comments
Scaevolus 3202 days ago
GCP VMs are per-minute, with a minimum of 10 minutes (vs AWS' new minimum of 1 minute). Second resolution is nice, but I doubt it makes much difference in pricing for most workloads. https://cloud.google.com/compute/pricing#billingmodel

Azure's containers don't use a full VM-- they're more like AWS Lambda or other serverless frameworks, so they do per-second billing with no minimums.

Disclaimer: I work at Google on Container Engine.

link
dsp1234 3202 days ago
Azure's EC2 equivalent is Azure Virtual Machines[0], which bills by the minute.

[0] - https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/services/virtual-machines/

"Keep your budget in check with low-cost, per-minute billing. You only pay for the compute time you use."

link
dastbe 3202 days ago
I would disagree on no minimums and equivalency to lambda et al, as azure container instances charge a create fee (iirc its equivalent to 100 seconds of their minimum configuration) which sits on top of the per-second billing.
link
doh 3202 days ago
We don't mind per-minute billing on GCP, but would love to get the minimum down to 1 minute or even less. We have some tasks that finish under 4 minutes where scaling horizontally instead of vertically makes much more sense to us.
link
andruby 3202 days ago
Hyper.sh runs docker containers, not VM's, and has per-second billing with a minimum of 10s.

I really want to use them to parallelise CI test runs, but haven't gotten round to setting this up yet.

link
alauda 3202 days ago
Check https://github.com/hyperhq/hykins
link
jopsen 3202 days ago
The minimum of 1 minute makes a difference... Granted 10min is not that much of a problem :)
link
jen20 3202 days ago
I was under the impression Azure was also per minute, and AWS was the last hold out of hourly billing among the big three until today.
link
tanilama 3202 days ago
Per-minute for GCP, but I am not sure it makes that much of a difference. Anyway, now the Game is on
link