| I wonder if this has any implications for recording? If someone is listening to a live musical instrument that is producing both audible sound and ultrasonic sound [1], is what the person perceives affected by intermodulation in the ear? If the performance is also recorded using a technology that for all practical purposes reproduces perfectly everything in the audible range, then I can see a couple possible cases. 1. The microphone is designed to filter out ultrasonics or is sufficient linear to not have intermodulation. In this case, the recording is what would be heard with no intermodulation. When played back, all the listener gets is the audible portion of the original sound, without any ultrasonics. Thus there is nothing to produce intermodulation in the listner's ear, and so the listener might perceive the recording as having a different timbre than the live instrument. 2. The microphone does not filter ultrasonics and is non-linear enough to have intermodulation. The audible intermodulation products will then be included in the recording. When played back the listener will hear intermodulation products, but they will be the ones from the microphone's non-linearity, not the ear's non-linearity. The question then is how close are microphone non-linearities to ear non-linearities. If they are similar, then the timbre of the recording should match live. If they are sufficiently different, the timbre could sound off. It should be possible to design a system that records only audible frequencies and plays back only audible frequencies and sounds identical to live, but it may require specifically taking into account ultrasonics instead of just cutting them out like I think we currently do. [1] A trumpet with a Harmon mute playing a quiet note has about 2% of its energy above 20 KHz. Playing a loud note drops that to about 0.5%. A cymbal crash is about 40% above 20 KHz. (Keys jangling are almost 70% above 20 KHz, which probably has something to do with why back in the early days of TV remote controls when they were ultrasonic instead of IR or RF people would report that if someone's keys jangled the channel would sometimes change). See: https://www.cco.caltech.edu/~boyk/spectra/spectra.htm |