Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lucaspiller 3214 days ago
You are ten years too late. The original OpenID did exactly this, and quite a few sites (especially tech focussed sites) let you sign in with it. Except then along came Google and Facebook with their proprietary login systems, and everyone jumped ship to those as they offered access to profiles rather than just a domain and possibly email address.
3 comments

We first worked in this problem at Netscape just after the AOL acquisition in 1998. It turns out to be impossible because: show me the money. Something we figured out within a few weeks back then.
Which is precisely why DNS and SMTP have failed miserably.
Please elaborate on how DNS has failed? It seems to me that everyone uses DNS all the time and is an essential component of the Internet as we know it, but you and I may have differing notions of failure.
I assume he was being sarcastic
Anyone would think the internet has become more closed in recent years or something
> You are ten years too late.

As in, what I want has been working for ten years?

I'm obviously not late at all, since websites still won't let me delegate my auth.

The few that allowed OpenID 10 years ago did let you delegate your auth. OAuth and OpenID Connect killed that.
I don't care that some technology exists. I want it to be widespread. OpenID had huge usability problems.
Not just the data but also using Facebook or Google accounts means your users are much more likely to be real people instead of spam bots.