Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by colmmacc 3219 days ago
It's not really a "vs" thing. EtM is implementation of AEAD.
1 comments
tptacek 3219 days ago
No, that's not accurate. EtM is an implementation technique. AEAD is a cryptographic primitive service model. The concepts aren't directly comparable.

In particular: you can easily end up with AE w/o AD by doing DIY ETM, and end up with serious exploitable bugs.

link
iofiiiiiiiii 3219 days ago
Can you go into more detail? What are the common gotchas when implementing ETM yourself?
link
tptacek 3219 days ago
The classic example is not MAC'ing the IV.
link
loup-vaillant 3218 days ago
Wait a minute, there are cases where this is required? Chacha20/Poly1305 is not one of them, right?

---

Another I have personally seen was using the session key for a Wegman Carter hash (such as Poly1305). I received an email suggesting I do just that in Monocypher, to avoid using up the beginning of the key stream. Didn't realise why this would lead to instant key recovery.

I have since littered my manual with scary tales of total annihilation of security.

link