Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by StavrosK 3234 days ago
Minimum guaranteed income everywhere.

Also cryptocurrencies (or at least one) becoming mainstream.

2 comments

Minimum guaranteed income is the beginning of the end. From a humanist perspective it is great, but that is short sighted. Human beings are goal driven, strip away the necessity of that basic human drive and who knows what can happen.

"Idle hands are the devil’s workshop"

The only thing motivating you is the fact that you'll starve if you don't work? That's some poor motivation, let me tell you.
I am never in fear of starvation. Western civilization was built on the bedrock of contributing to society through labor. It's how the system works. That whole system will have to change if that axiom disappears. It is very naive to think that wont have a massive effect on mate selection, how people spend their time, morals, etc.

This isnt purely about economics. There are other deeper issues at play when you say people no longer need to work.

You're assuming that people won't want to work if they don't have to worry about starving, which I'm not sure is a valid assumption at all.
Sure, everyone will keep being disciplined, waking up early to a work a shitty office job. They will keep doing data entry for 40k a year and cleaning up public toilets for 35k a year. They will put up with massive stress and the risk of being laid off at a large corporation
Oh, your argument is that people should be under massive stress? Nice.
> Minimum guaranteed income

Would this work? Isn't it like "everyone above average"? If everyone gets a minimum amount of money, money will be worth less. It would make more sense to guarantee certain resources, or more targeted welfare (e.g. that comes with requirements on how it is spent).