Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by EliRivers 3231 days ago
Yet if I want to make a serious study of something, I hit the textbooks. The internet is, in my experience, a poor replacement for a stack of well written physical textbooks.

The internet may be a big library, but in many ways it's not a very good one.
2 comments
sol_remmy 3231 days ago
Counterpoint: My friends all went through mechanical engineering WITHOUT reading textbooks - that was the secret to their success.

No one is going to touch the textbooks in a library.

link
EliRivers 3231 days ago
Did a master's in maths with the internet in front of me the whole time. Learned almost entirely from textbooks on my desk. The internet was useful for discussing problems and ordering books from the local library.

The secret to my success was reading the textbooks and working through them. Had perhaps twenty days of formal instruction throughout, but when I added up the hours spent it was effectively me and the books for a time equal to eight months' full-time. Couldn't have done it without simply hitting the books. Can't speak for your chums. Maybe they learned in classes or lectures or practical sessions or some such. For me, it was hitting the books.

link
jogjayr 3231 days ago
Counter-counter point. My wife went through a graphic design degree without ever buying a textbook (many of which were required for class). She borrowed them from our local library, leveraging the inter-library loan system when needed. It saved her hundreds of $$
link
goialoq 3231 days ago
How did MechE's succeed before the Internet?
link
sol_remmy 3231 days ago
Haha - my friends dad also did MechE in the 80s. He says MechE students now are responsible for learning much more material.

I'd say the internet has allowed more material to be taught in four years.

link
icebraining 3231 days ago
Alternatively, that could be an argument for digitalizing those textbooks and offering them for free.

Maybe Bezos should fund Libgen :)

link
EliRivers 3231 days ago
I can't speak for anyone else, but every textbook I used during a master's in maths was available on the screen in front of me. I used paper textbooks instead. They're simply much better for serious learning.
link