[redler]

You may be right in this case, but is there any discipline more rife with no-true-Scotsman rejoinders in its defense?

[ju-st]

Well I don't know any other disciplines where so many people are implementing an idea so badly :-)

See my another post for a real discussion of an issue is see with OP's post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15004260