Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by endorphone 3253 days ago
A sub-concussion doesn't require that you hit your head. It simply requires a g-force event -- like skiing quickly over rough terrain -- that shakes the brain around, building up the scar tissue that we know as CTE. Offensive linesmen engage with the opponent via their body/arms, seldom hitting with their head, but that rapid g-force of the body stopping is enough.

Again, someone studied football players because the impact is obvious. As it reaches out, players in even relatively low-g sports like soccer are being found with CTE.
1 comments
switchbak 3253 days ago
Having played the game for years, I can assure you the impact being generated on the line is very real. These folks do interact with their body/arms, but head on head contact is a very real part of the game, and that is the part that really affects the brain.

And the part of soccer that seems to cause concern is heading the ball, not the running around part.

Comparing helmet to helmet impacts to skiing over rough terrain feels like a real stretch here.

link
endorphone 3253 days ago
And the part of soccer that seems to cause concern is heading the ball

But we don't know what the concern is in soccer. Heading is immediately looked at because it's an impact, but the actual cause may be something altogether different.

I mentioned the g forces measured in skiing elsewhere. They are absolutely in the range of subconcussion.

link