Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by danesparza 3267 days ago
It sounds like The API changed. But same sentiment -- that was a shit design decision.
2 comments

It sounds like locking down the API was an entirely deliberate decision made at the same time as removing platform data from the website, which means Chesterton's fence[0] applies - we should work out why that decision was made before criticising it.

Discussion upthread is about commuters being pushed onto the tracks, which sounds like a good reason not to display data that isn't 100% certain.

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Chesterton's fence

I've never heard of "Chesterton's Fence" before and appreciate the introduction to the term. That said, I don't think your application is correct. The OP in this case is not the agent of change — he did not "reform" anything and does not have the capacity to act, he just analyzed/synthesized existing data.

(Also, on reflection, "Chesterton's Fence" is an unnecessarily complicated and overly verbose way of saying: "The MTA probably has a reason for the change.")

> we should work out why that decision was made

Good luck with that. I'd be amazed if you got a response.

The API didn't change, they just made it private "for MTA use only"