Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by a_gopher 3271 days ago
Paper doesn't address what measures the aliens might use to disguise any obvious signature of the starshade.

You'd think that the aliens might not be too keen to create huge beacon advertising their presence to all and sundry...

3 comments

One cannot assume that an alien can think in a fashion similar to Earth animals.

Humans have the ability to imagine a possibility for which no supporting evidence currently exists--that species alien to our solar system might exist. That ability might not be shared by the species we can imagine. That is, humans can imagine a species that cannot imagine humans. Such aliens would not even realize that building a planet-sized object that cannot be explained by natural processes might present an existential risk.

We, of course, are afraid of hypervelocity impact weaponry, even while having no evidence whatsoever that any such weapon exists anywhere in the universe.

Of course, that just means that any species that did fear annihilation by near-c rocks smashing into their planet would simply disguise their star shade so well that we could not detect it. Meaning that any solar shade we can detect was not likely built by any species able to think like us.

We could clean up by selling them insurance.

I'm not sure how you propose a species that can't imagine things that don't exist would advance technologically to space travel.
Investigation of serendipitous results.
They may not need imagination if they can build dyson spheres, new telescopes could help verify where we should put our efforts at contact: http://www.sciencealert.com/researchers-just-found-a-second-...
There is no stealth in space.

Therefore, instead of hiding, the aliens are going to pro-actively fry every competitor civilization by using their solar shades as a Nicoll Dyson Beam... :-)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjtFnWh53z0

Best disguise would be reduced solare output or another inner sync planet giving partial shade..