[TMBest]

If you're not known enough about China, you should not claim "That is a lot of money for a working class Chinese person." Actually, 19 yuan is ignorable for working class Chinese person. You can only buy about 1 hamburger in McDonalds, or buy 0.5 kilogram pork, or buy a bowl of noodle by using 19 yuan (delicious noodle costs at least double). China has changed a lot. If you have time, you can visit Shanghai, Beijing, and many other cities. You'll find they're all modern and safe cities, and you'll find your claim is totally wrong.

[seanmcdirmid]

19 kuai is almost a lunch at a xiaochi.

To a lot of people, however, 19 kuai is still a lot, especially a migrant worker or an old ayi. Also, I wouldn't call Beijing a modern safe city, Shanghai sure, but Beijing is definitely 3rd tier pretending to be 1st.

[stupidcar]

So, I know nothing much about China, but the story certainly backs this up. The 19 yuan is a deposit. If it really is a day's wages, then that would provide an incredibly strong incentive to return the umbrella and reclaim the deposit.

[balls187]

You both likely have different definitions of "working class."

[LeifCarrotson]

I'm friends with a "working class" translator (4 year Business English degree) in Shanghai who lives in a 6000 RMB/month apartment and drives a 1-year-old VW. That's one working class. 15 years ago, though, as a child of subsistence farmers in rural China, though, she was happy to sweep the town streets with a bamboo-shoot broom for the princely sum of 10 RMB/hour.

There's a huge level of income disparity between rural and urban Chinese - even more than SF vs flyover USA.