Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by pdkl95 3262 days ago
> boost the clarity of softer sections or to make louder sections more comfortable to the ears

You can create these effects during playback with a compressor, which are available in many players[1]. Knowledge about compressors isn't as widely known as it should be; it's an important feature that would help a lot of people, especially anyone dealing with hearing loss.

> headphones

Maybe try better headphones (or a different type, such as enclosed headphones with good room attenuation)? Many cheap[2] headphones have terrible response to different volumes; quieter parts may be overly attenuated, for example. Cheap/bad headphones also tend to have a highly variable frequency response, which can sometimes sound like volume problems. If this is the case, spending some time with a highly configurable EQ might help (possibly in addition to a compressor).

[1] also available in some audio systems (e.g. jack) and as a feature in some drivers/soundcards

[2] and some "name brand", such as older Bose, anything Beats or other brands sold as fashion statements.

edit: re-added sentence that died during a bad copy/paste

edit2: Appendix for anybody that isn't familiar with dynamic range compression.

> need to adjust the volume several times

This is literally what a basic compressor is automating[3] for you. It turns down the output volume when the input level is over a threshold. There are a lot of (often configurable) details like how much to reduce the volume as the input level increases past the threshold, how quickly[4] it responds to a loud transient, and how quickly it returns to normal when the input becomes quiet again. Really nice compressors even smooth[5] the changes near the threshold so the whole effect is less noticeable.

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamic_range_compression#Desi...

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamic_range_compression#Atta...

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamic_range_compression#Soft...

1 comments

I knew about them and the copy of Android I had installed on my phone included compression.

Like most things in that OS it's very buggy, one day it just dumped full volume noise into my headphones and that really hurt. After that I hardly trust anything in Android to handle audio and don't like plugging headphones into my phone.

Out of curiosity, when did that happen?