Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by walterbell 3273 days ago
If you delete the Facebook cookie (i.e. are completely logged out including username), then click on a link in an email notification from Facebook, it will silently log you in again, restoring the cookie and web-wide tracking. This can be tested by pasting an email notification link to a new private browsing window.
3 comments

If you use PrivacyBadger you don't have more facebook cookie on 3rd party websites, so they dont track you.

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-us/firefox/addon/privacy-badge...

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/privacy-badger/pke...

also firefox "containers" now allow you to use a separate cookie set for different domains.

https://testpilot.firefox.com/experiments/containers/

I used it a few weeks ago in test-pilot program, it was hard to use, difficult to open new tabs in container I wanted.
Yeah, it wasn't that helpful. In the last few weeks they made it so you can right click on a page once opened in a container and "always open in this container"
How do you login to Facebook when needed, if there is no cookie?
It only blocks third-party cookies, so you can login to Facebook. What it would block is Facebook tracking outside the Facebook domain. Another option is to use something like Self-destructing cookies, which would delete the Facebook cookie when you close the tab.
Edited comment to explain it affects 3rd party websites. Facebook works as usually and all content it the same.
Thanks for the pointer. Wish this worked on iOS, where the only option is to use a dedicated browser for accessing Facebook. Not sure how Brave deals with Facebook cookies on iOS.
Why can't you use firefox on iOS? All addons should work normally.

https://www.mozilla.org/en-GB/firefox/ios/

Apple does not allow browser extensions. Firefox (any non-Apple browser) on iOS is a wrapper around Mobile Safari.
So, they're spewing login credentials all throughout users' emails? How is their security team okay with this?

Do they require that it be from a previously used IP/user-agent or something?

Works with a VPN, so not linked to IP. URL includes email used for FB auth.

Edit: received FB email about "login from unknown device".

But that can easily be explained as a feature, not a bug.
Most other sites do not automatically transfer your username and password/token from (insecure) email to web. Most other sites require authentication for a fully-logged-out user.