Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Flow 5834 days ago
http://cappuccino.org/ and some python on the backend for REST interaction.

Or GWT, just like GMail.

1 comments

Not to be snarky but, GMail isn't written in GWT.

GWT though would be a step towards the OP's solution.

How sure are you in your claim? Any proof that GMail is not written in GWT?
Here is proof:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=56758

(Paul Buchheit was GMail's creator and lead developer)

Also, here is more proof:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=190151

You could tell me: "OK, but it doesn't prove that current GMail is not in GWT. It may have been rewritten". I'd answer that:

- using firebug and looking at the js scripts loaded by GMail, there is no trace of GWT (things such as *.nocache.js scripts). They might have obfuscated to hide it, but why do that?

- if Google indeed rewrote GMail using GWT, they would have announced it, like they did for Wave / Adwords.

More discussion in this other thread: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1470633

Gmail was written using Closure library built by google itself. Google release it for open source community now.
That is not proof, just another statement that means nothing without supporting data.

Also, if GMail is such a successful use case for Closure library, one could wonder why did they build Google Wave client with GWT?

GMail predates GWT by at least 2 years.