Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ajdlinux 3282 days ago
Pretty sure NFC transactions are "offline", i.e. the round trip to the bank happens after the card has left the reader.
4 comments

Often the round trip to the bank happens after the card has left the reader but before the txn is authorised (i.e. the device prints a receipt, customer gets the product or service), that's still an online transaction.
Sometimes.

Paying for the bus for me is offline, whereas in a supermarket it's processed online

That's probably optional, I usually get an Amex push notification from NFC transactions right after they occur (before I have time to put my phone back in my pocket).
This is correct. Which is why there is a low 'floor limit' on NFC/Contactless payments. Your card is not actually authorised at point of transaction.
From experience in two European countries, this is not always the case. I have both a Visa and MC cards which can be used in contactless mode for transactions of any size, up to the card limit. For low amounts (<40EUR) the PIN is not requested. For larger transactions I have to enter the PIN, but I don't need the chip.
In the UK, Contactless is PIN free, hence the low floor limit. Anything over that amount (£30 typically) requires Chip+PIN, and remote authentication.
Just from my personal experiance in Switzerland I think this is mostly the case, but not always. I have a contactless Visa with a rather low limit that I use for small day to day purchases. I only use it contactless and most of the time I can go over the monthly limit if I only use it contactless. Sometimes if I do this it will still be declined by a shop due to «insufficient funds», so some contactless terminals must be calling home. At this point the Card stops working at any terminal, even the contactless kind. I have to wait for the next month and use it the Chip and Pin way once to make it work again.