Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by petervandijck 5836 days ago
ok that's crazy. Is scribd becoming the new pdf (I mean that in a good way)?
3 comments

The only thing I could applaud more would be a new (and simpler) cross platform document format (for asset encapsulation and offline viewing) that could be transformed to and from HTML on a whim. Scribd <-> My Screen <-> My Printer. To death with PDF.

Come to think of it HTML5/CSS3 + an open archive/compression format would suit this purpose nicely.

What is your problem with PDF?

Almost any browser other than lynx has a buitin pdf reader, and pdf can be created by just about anything.

Finally pdf is a format that allow you to ensure that no matter where it is printed, it is exactly as you wanted it to be.

The problem with pdf is that everything about it is clunky and slow. I didn't decide to groan whenever I see that something I want is trapped inside a pdf; years of annoyance just built that up as a reflex.

Edit: actually, there is an exception, and you mentioned it: printing a pdf, once you have it open, is almost always a good experience. Too bad it's the thing I want to do least often.

You've just described ePub.
I'm looking for visual and layout consistency across all mediums (screen, print, etc) and in my experience ePub isn't suited for that. My apology for the lack of clarity.
A web service replacing a document format?
Probably not until it doesn't look terrible (on Windows 7 with Chrome).