Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sliverstorm 5839 days ago
Perhaps; perhaps not. There's many situations it would be worthwhile.

- They want to kill us just because

- They have already occupied virtually everywhere else, and want more (our) space

- We are in the way of their wave of expansion, and they don't care (and are set to steam-roller over us)

- Earth or nearby planets are valuable to both them and us, and equivalents are too far away (nobody says FTL travel is possible)

There have been plenty of wars (not every single one, but plenty) here on Earth already that demonstrate that.
1 comments
metamemetics 5839 days ago
The fact that a human has killed another human in the past is hardly sufficient reason for recommending Xenocide as de facto future policy, mein Fuher.
link
sliverstorm 5839 days ago
Did you examine my hypothetical scenarios? They all basically revolve around another race that wants to commit xenocide on us. Or can you simply not conceive of a scenario where humans are not the superior species calling the shots? If we are not the only sentient race, then there's bound to be quite a few out there, and I can guarantee you we aren't the best, the strongest, the most adept or adaptable, or the most competent. There's always someone better, and odds are if the other race finds us, they are superior (they managed to go exploring and expanding before us).

The history of human wars is purely an example demonstrating that even when there is enough land to go around, there are times when you have to fight (unless of course you are ambivalent towards your own survival). To use your apparently favorite example, Hitler, America engaged in WWII and yet did not win a scrap of land. Nor did America want land. Was this just some stupid unjustified, unreasonable mistake?

link
metamemetics 5839 days ago
Straw man, argument 'self-defense == bad' not present.

Possible arguments:

1) The ethics (and humor) of pre-emptive strikes

2) Given that the proportion of resource-containing matter forming planets inhabited by sentient life to total resource-containing matter in the galaxy approaches insignificance, it seems extremely improbable that homo sapiens will ever be engaged in a competition for resources with sentient alien life at a time point where homo sapiens still exist and have not evolved into several other species.

link