Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cjak 3327 days ago
I do not undertake projects having an immediate or exclusive military application.

Beyond that, I pick and choose based on my gut.

1 comments

Would you make an exception for something purely defensive, like an ICBM interceptor?
ICBM interceptors are (among other things) for neutralizing an enemy's retaliatory deterrence thus enabling the protected party to carry out nuclear first strikes. They are not purely defensive.
I'm not sure if it's helpful to think about things that way because it can be applied to just about everything. Does body armor make war more likely because we can kill more of theirs than they can kill ours? Does that mean personal body armor can not by considered purely defensive?
> I'm not sure if it's helpful to think about things that way because it can be applied to just about everything.

It can be applied to just about anything (well, anything combat-related) because, in fact, nothing combat-related is purely defensive; it's all, including things whose direct use is protective, developed and acquired in order to improve the ability to destroy the enemy.

It's not helpful to delude oneself into believing that the purely defensive exists.