Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by compton_effect 3331 days ago
cool idea but I'm gonna assume its a lot more expensive to send up an X-37 and have it crash back down then it is too just send a few nukes at your target.
2 comments

If you look at it purely from a costs perspective, maybe.

Don't discount the PR disaster that would ensue from the US using nukes in any scenario other than retaliation for a nuclear attack. Nukes used in anger would likely mean worldwide condemnation, sanctions, and pissed allies complaining about fallout.

Preface: I don't think this is a likely explanation.

But if you think it is, there's a big advantage of kinetic weapons over ICBMs, namely that they are a lot more credible as a first strike weapon. ICBMs launches are quite detectable, allowing counter strikes (hi there nuclear deterrence).