Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sheetjs 3341 days ago
It's all relative. Sometimes solutions require insights. Other times solutions involve a ton of grinding. Many people have a tendency to overemphasize the first and greatly underemphasize the second, even though the grinding may actually be harder than devising clever solutions.

We build tools that read and write Excel files (open source library: https://github.com/sheetjs/js-xlsx) There are plenty of very difficult problems involving ill-specified aspects of the various file formats and errors in specifications, but it is largely a matter of grinding and finding files in the wild that capture the behavior you want to understand. Those are "difficult" in the sense that people still get these things wrong (related: recently a bug in the Oracle SmartView corrupted US Census XLS exports, which boiled down to an issue in calculating string lengths with special characters) but they don't feel difficult since most of the work didn't involve any really clever insights.

IMHO the hardest problem is now fairly straightforward: How do you enable people to test against confidential files? The solution involves running the entire process in the web browser using FileReader API: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/FileReader , and that is an obvious technical solution in 2017 but few thought it was even possible when we started.
2 comments
aidos 3341 days ago
That's actually my default response when people intimate the work I do must be complex / I must be clever - it's really just hard graft. Sometimes you just have to be willing / stubborn enough to chip away at a problem that initially seems insurmountable. Sure, the more knowledge you accumulate, the faster you can figure out when to look, but often enough you just need to roll up your sleeves and bisect your search space.

I can imagine you get some pretty warty excel files. I mostly get PDF for my sins. I'm sure, like me, you've spent hours taking bits out of files until they work as expected and then figuring out what the difference is :-)

link
LrnByTeach 3341 days ago
I totally agree with these gems ...

> It's all relative. Sometimes solutions require insights. Other times solutions involve a ton of grinding.

> Many people have a tendency to overemphasize the first and greatly under emphasize the second, even though the grinding may actually be harder than devising clever solutions.

> No individual problem is hard. It's arguably hard to do tedious work day in and day out for months at a time, but I don't think people would call that "technically hard".

link