Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jakeogh 3345 days ago
Do we really need the /s tag on something so obvious?
3 comments

Unfortunately, yes. Keep in mind that in text any vocal tone and visual clues are lost, and a lot of sarcasm is signaled those ways, so some additional indication in text is useful.

Also, Poe's law is alive and well here. You assumed it was sarcasm, but I'm not so sure. It's not too far fetched for me to imagine someone thinks mashing up bugs to spread on a plastic bag is horrible. See my first paragraph for the solution to this...

Oh sure because satire wasn't commonplace in books long before the internet. How would those poor souls have figured it out it wasn't serious?! IMPOSSIBLE.

Regarding Poe's law, if it looks like sarcasm assume it is and move on, but I understand that commenting on the internet is of utmost importance and a task that shouldn't be taken lightly.

For what it's worth, in books and other print media it is usually easier to tell if a piece of text is sarcasm or not based on context.
What /s tag? It seems genuine and has NO TAG.
I didn't think it was sarcasm. Its a bit sad that they had to squash up the bugs just to run that test.