Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by diminoten 3352 days ago
I love chess, and own these books. It was a pleasant (if a little bewildering) surprise to find this submission on HN.

One thing I don't love about chess is how eager everyone seems to be to apply concepts and principles from chess to non-chess situations, implying that an understanding of these principles within the game will provide a better understanding of their analogous situations outside of chess.

People tend to claim that being good at chess will make you good at other things too, but I've always found that being good at chess makes you... good at chess, and that's about it.

Edit: My favorite article on chess is from an 1859 Scientific American, and can be found here: https://books.google.com/books?id=90hGAQAAIAAJ&pg=PA9&dq=%22...

An excerpt:

> ...chess is a mere amusement of a very inferior character, which robs the mind of valuable time that might be devoted to nobler acquirements, while at the same time it affords no benefit whatsoever to the body.

Oh, if they knew the kinds of things we spent our time on now...

2 comments

Chess taught me many things about life: think ahead, sacrifice for an advantage, patience, and setting the stage in preparation to execute a strategy which I use as a lawyer often.
I don't mean to offend, but aren't these all sort of...common sense?
Yes, if common sense was common, it would be common sense :).

In my "career" of chess, I still learn things after 12 years. This year my focus is to not downtalk myself before a game against a strong opponent. It is part of my personality to do that. I also do that in more common situations. Chess just provides a way to battle your own shortcomings and improve yourself.

Other things I learn by playing chess... Always play till the end, untill there are no more chances. Only then give up. I learned to lose better, and am still learning that. The less I am afraid of losing, the more freeflowing my gameplay is. I learned to find my way better in chaotic situations and I actually love them. I like to find the moves and game-style that gives a bit of bewonderment and inspiration.

And yes, you can learn something everywhere. You just have to pick your battles and where to fight/play them. Chess fits my personality, it does a lot to me.

I can relate to this a lot. The lessons of finding one's way in chaotic situations and learning not to fear them in particular did carry over into real life along with several other lessons.
Interesting. Thanks for the response.
It's the difference between "knowing" something is a good idea and actually comprehending why since you've seen it executed successfully and understand the consequences for and against that idea. Now you understand the core concepts and don't just "know" it because it's "common sense". Huge difference.
That reminds me of an SMBC comic which coincidentally mentions chess when joking about a similar idea. http://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2010-01-29