Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dogecoinbase 3352 days ago
Imagine if you weren't allowed to debug or write tests for your own code.

Yes, this is exactly how we QA in fields where software errors can cost lives.

1 comments

I could see the merit in this, would you mind elaborating a little bit?
My experience is in medical equipment -- not quite the mess that medical devices are, thankfully. The general idea is a combination of redundancy, clean-room methods, and people whose domain expertise is in testing and edge case analysis.

From a personal perspective, I find that trying to design tests as the developer of the code to be tested is fundamentally difficult -- I have embedded assumptions around the functionality of the code that make it cognitively difficult to fully envision complex failure scenarios. Some of the best test producers I've worked with have had no development background at all.