Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mafribe 3354 days ago
I'd be interested to learn how web-dev in OCaml->JS compares to web-dev with Scala.js. The latter has the amazing JVM eco-system to hand.

(I'm not interested in a Scala vs Ocaml language comparison. I know both languages very well. I'd be interested in the quality of JS support.)
1 comments
wtetzner 3354 days ago
> The latter has the amazing JVM eco-system to hand.

What do you mean? Scala.js allows you to use things from the Java ecosystem in JavaScript?

link
virtualwhys 3354 days ago
Only if it's been ported to Scala.js; in fact, same goes for Scala to Scala.js, all libs need to be cross compiled.

The only thing you get for "free" in Scala.js is Scala, which is of course no small accomplishment, but the JVM ecosystem as a whole does not come with it.

link
wtetzner 3353 days ago
That's what I thought, and why I was confused by the original comment. Scala.js doesn't seem to have any benefits over js_of_ocaml, unless you prefer the language itself.
link
mafribe 3353 days ago
I was expressing myself sloppily, sorry. You still can use many things in the JVM ecosystem because you can compile (most of) scala.js not only to Javascript but also to the JVM, and then analyse the code with JVM specific tools like fuzzers, debuggers, profilers etc. This is powerful. Making sure your code runs on two platform will expose additional problems that one platform alone doesn't do.
link
wtetzner 3345 days ago
I see. Well, I suppose that's true of OCaml as well. Its ecosystem is smaller, but it does have some pretty powerful tools, including a time-traveling debugger.
link