Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by 0xCMP 3352 days ago
Devil's Advocate: Kind of goes with the idea that the characters are unrealistic right?
2 comments

Yes, the characters are intended to be one dimensional. You'll notice all the characters have differences from each other in important ways, because they are meant to show how certain beliefs (and contradictions in beliefs) interact and have consequences.

Dagny and Rearden have internal contradictions, and it's not the point to find relation to them as people, but how their contradictions affect them.

The one sided villains aren't meant to be rich characters full of life, but people who carry out principles you here uttered in real life to their extreme conclusions.

The purpose is to take people at what they claim their values are and illustrate their implications.

People have argued that, but I don't buy it.

We have captains of industry that we hero worship today.

Devil's Advocate: Jesus was the son of God, but we don't ignore his ideals as unrealistic.