Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tluyben2 3355 days ago
But these laws (same as in Spain where I live) are there for protectionism and that is, very visibly in these two countries, not a good thing for 'the people'.
1 comments

I think we should let "the people" decide what is good for them, and not us doing it for them. Italy is a democratic country with a government and legal system that is upholding the laws. The court ruling appears to be in line with those laws, so i don't see a problem here.

Keep in mind, this is Europe and not the US. The argument "more car-based transportation at lower prices is good for everyone" is not necessarily something that the majority of the population in Italy or elsewhere in Europe is necessarily aspiring to. So if the government - at state and local level - is keeping the number of taxis in check by high taxes/fees while subsidizing green or mass transit, thats OK too. And the government of Italy has every right to do that. just my two cents.

Is anyone advocating for invading Italy to change its laws? All the talk about Italy having the right to do what it wants is a strawman, nobody argues they don't have that right.