Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by revscat 3367 days ago
Which is interesting in itself. You seem to think that the bot usage took away from the overall importance of the effort. I'm not sure I agree.
2 comments

I don't disagree that it's still interesting (if a bit boring after the first few frames of an animated representation of the progress). But a piece of art created by a few dozen people with machines, when compared to the expectation that a piece of art was created by a couple hundred thousand people by hand; well, it just doesn't have the same impact.
But the machines were only built and deployed as a reaction to human energies? If there were no people participating as they were, then no one would have gone to the efforts to build and run the bots. I feel your comment seems to gloss over how important the human factor was to bringing the more "mechanical" part into existence :)

EDIT: speaking of which, I wonder if reddit could use some of the data from this to detect sockpuppet network on reddit... I imagine communities of a certain type might have engaged (or not) with this phenomenon in a very different way than others

It definitely does, viewing it as "collaborative art" when really it's just a bunch of people running bots to smash other people's shit turns it from "art" to a popularity contest of standard internet practice pretty fast.