[xapata]

Ah yes, with a good idea, the rest is just "a simple matter of implementation."

[theparanoid]

Look at YCombinator startups, most fail to come up with a product that people will actually pay money for.

[builditand]

This proves that bad ideas exist, not that the idea is the most important or difficult part.

[xapata]

Maybe it was the right product, but the implementation was shoddy. We'll never know.