Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rxlim 3371 days ago
My biggest wish is Ubuntu (and Debian) switching from systemd to any other init system. I know that won't happen but I was asked and that's the only thing I want, whenever you like it or not.
5 comments

also check https://www.devuan.org

we are very close to release Jessie stable, backed by a vibrant community

http://distrowatch.com/table.php?distribution=devuan

For those preferring an introductory video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wMvyOGawNwo

Just saw the video and must say that it has really sparked my interest in Devuan. I heard of Devuan when the fork was first announced but never gave it much notice, now is the first time I try to understand what it really is. It seems like Devuan is much more organized and well-thought than I imagined. This is music to my ears:

Devuan will do its best to stay minimal and abide to the UNIX philosophy of "doing one thing and doing it well". It will foster diversity and freedom of choice among all its components and will perceive itself not as an end product, but as a a process, a starting point for developers, a viable base for sysadmins and a stable tool for people who have enough experience with computers. Devuan will never compromise for more efficiency at the cost of the freedom of its users, rather than leave that and the responsibility for a secure setup to downstream developers.

I need to do much more research and of course testing, but Devuan could be light at the end of the tunnel.

I'm poised to try out Void Linux after trying out FreeBSD (it was missing too many conveniences like Dropbox and Steam).

Could you convince me why I should try Devuan instead?

I need to make much more research before I will convince anyone, but as a start I like the philosophy of Devuan very much.

I have moved many many servers from Debian to FreeBSD after the announcement of systemd, and this has been great, but I must agree with you that on the desktop it can be a little inadequate.

Hasn't Devuan be "close" to a stable release for 2.5 years or so now?
The first thing I did after reading the Ask HN was Ctrl+F 'systemd'.
This is a big part of why I moved away from Ubuntu. I know this is a difficult situation - whenever Ubuntu tries to find a better solution it gets flak for dividing the community. But here it would have been great to have Ubuntu with an alternative to the disaster that is systemd.
I'm curious what init system would you prefer?
I would really like to see s6 in Ubuntu, but sysvinit + OpenRC would also be fine.
Why? You need to develop your answer.
I want software to be simple, well-engineered and lightweight. In my opinion systemd is the exact opposite of that. I think this page explains it well: http://suckless.org/sucks/systemd

In practice I have had many extremely frustrating problems with systemd including systems that suddenly became unbootable.