Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by incogitomode 3378 days ago
For two years now I've used iCloud Music Library (iTunes Match) to handle exactly the sort of situation the article author describes. Bucking the trend here; I love it.

I've written a number of scripts (the main one is on npm) that run on a home Mac Mini server, converting FLAC to ALAC, and copying music which gets added to the library via the iTunes Add to Library folder.

Within minutes of hitting a synced drop folder music is converted, stored and uploaded. I then have access to that music on my phone and computer. I can access 100% of my personal 40k track library anywhere, and can listen lossless at home. I still have music in my library I ripped in the early 2000s.

I've definitely hated on iTunes plenty — the search is unforgivably slow and CPU intensive, and the app seems forever going backwards on usability.

Still, I have what seems like a miracle of the cloud. A reliable, personal streaming service, with none of the restrictions of Spotify or Apple Music. I'll deal with the inconvenience.

For the record: I've explored a similar system with Google Play, but Apple manages the best end-to-end ecosystem across devices in my opinion.

3 comments

I'm also generally +1 on iTunes Match. However recently I've noticed my iPhone skipping songs frequently, no matter how hard I try I can't get those songs to play. I'm not sure if the fault is with my phone, itunes, match or something else, but it's not as seamless as I'd have liked.

It took me a while to notice as usually I'm not watching the screen of my phone when I"m shuffling around and such, but now that I know it happens i've been watching for it.

It happens to be occasionally too. I've ended up exporting and re-importing those tracks on the server and it tends to fix it.

Definitely an annoyance, but infrequent enough that I had forgotten about it until you mentioned.

This is pretty much to a t my thoughts on iTunes. iTunes Match is everything I want and need it to be for on-the-go but leaves me a with a bit to be desired elsewhere.

It's good enough for me, I've given up on syncing my music on iPhone (do still do local backups)...

I actually use Subsonic in jukebox mode, coupled with the amazing Dsub for Android for my home listening. It looks at the same directory as iTunes, and outputs via USB to an external DAC / amplifier.
What would you do if you didn't want to pay for it?